Wrapper Redemption Review at the 2013 National Sports Collectors Convention

redemptionsFrom July 31 to August 4, Chicago was host of the 34th National Sports Collectors Convention. I attended the show and participated in the redemption programs held by Panini and Upper Deck.

For those who have never done a redemption program at a card show before, it basically goes like this: You buy packs or boxes of cards at the show and open them up at a company’s booth. In turn, you get special packs that contains cards you can only get at the show.

Here is my rundown of the Panini and Upper Deck redemption programs at the 2013 National.

Panini_logoPanini
To participate in Panini’s redemption program, you had to buy an entire box of cards. You would get a specific amount of redemption packs based on what box of cards you purchased.

For example, I bought a box of 2013-14 Score Hockey jumbo packs, which merited me four redemption packs. Thus, a redemption pack of Panini cards would cost you about $25, and only had two cards.

Here are the highlights from my four Panini redemption packs.

panini_crosby panini_toews

The set was made up of athletes from all sports, and was a tougher set to put together, since you’d only get two cards and the redemption set was around 30 cards or so.

Panini’s redemption also had a greater variety of hits — including autographed cards, exchange cards for an over-sized autographed card, jersey cards and jersey/autograph combo cards. I pulled one jersey card from my four redemption packs:

barnes_guI never heard of Harrison Barnes, but he must be popular because there’s like ten of this card on eBay right now.

I only participated in Panini’s program once, earning four packs. For me, it was too expensive of a program to participate in further. But it was well-received by many other collectors, as evidenced by the high amount of foot traffic in Panini’s booth during the convention.

UD_logo

Upper Deck
Upper Deck’s redemption program was a little more streamlined. Their 20-card redemption set was a bit easier to assemble. On Thursday, you could get cards 1-5. On Friday, cards 6-10. Saturday’s redemption packs had cards 11-15 and Sunday’s packs had cards 16-20. So, if you went every day and got one redemption pack each day, you’d get all of the cards needed for the set. Of course, you had to then participate every day.

Upper Deck’s redemption program was also a bit cheaper to buy into. For the cost of two packs of Fleer Retro Hockey ($12), you could get an Upper Deck redemption pack. However, you were limited to four packs per day.

Here is what the set looks like:

ud_gretzky ud_saadThere were athletes from other sports in the 20-card set, but 5 of the cards were of hockey players, so no complaints here.

As for “hits,” Upper Deck kept it simple, offering only autographed cards as an incentive. Their lineup was pretty good, though, and I was lucky enough to get two autographed cards:

auto_toewsauto_lebronAs you can see, I got one autograph from a damn good hockey player, and a damn good basketball player.

My rate of success with the Upper Deck redemption packs was better because I participated in their program every day, getting four packs each time. I liked their program better because it was easier to assemble the redemption set and the “hits” were bigger. And if you got a hit, it was in addition to the five “regular” cards already in the pack.

Did anyone else participate in either redemption program at the National this year? If so, how did you do?

Five great effects of the Gretzky trade

1988-89 O-Pee-Chee Leaders #11 - Wayne GretzkyTwenty-five years ago today, Wayne Gretzky was traded from the Edmonton Oilers to the Los Angeles Kings. As an American hockey fan, I feel like I owe a lot to Wayne Gretzky. His presence on a U.S.-based team helped grow the sport here in the states tremendously. The effects of his trade are still felt in this country today.

Here are five effects of the “Gretzky Trade” that made hockey better, especially in the U.S.:

snl_1
How many other hockey players have hosted Saturday Night Live?

1. Gretzky gave hockey a “go-to” reference in the United States.
If you asked a random person on the street in a U.S. city to name a hockey player back in 1987, they probably would have answered you with a blank stare. Sure, a hockey fan would have been able to rattle off an entire roster, but not a lot of people outside of hockey circles knew much about the sport, let alone who the greatest player was.

Gretzy’s trade to the Kings gave the second-largest market in the U.S. the best hockey player ever. People took note, and Gretzky became that “go-to” hockey reference that  the U.S. so sorely needed.

  • Gretzky hosted Saturday Night Live in 1989; the first and only hockey player to do so
  • Gretzky was the “hockey character” in the God-awful Saturday morning cartoon ProStars, which also featured animated versions of Michael Jordan and Bo Jackson.
  • In the 1990 film Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, one of the turtles makes a remarks, “Who the heck is that, Wayne Gretzky?” when meeting goalie-masked vigilante Casey Jones. A generation of kids watching that film who had no idea who Wayne Gretzky even was would soon find out.

The list goes on. The mainstream population in the U.S. may not have ever watched a hockey game, but at least they could now name the game’s best player.

1988-89 Topps #120 - Wayne Gretzky
The trade that changed trading cards.

2. Gretzky’s trade changed trading cards.
Gretzky’s trade changed hockey cards in two ways. First, up until the late 1980s, Topps and O-Pee-Chee would “doctor” a photo if a player was traded in the offseason, so as to make the player “appear” that he was with his new team. They’d either do a “head swap,” or paint a new uniform over the old one.

But you don’t do that to the Great One.

Instead of painting a Kings uniform over a game-action shot of Gretzky — or worse, transplanting his head on another player’s body — the Topps card company used a photo of Gretzky from a press conference on their 1988-89 trading card.

Other companies would follow suit. Hoops used a similar photo for their 1989-90 card of David Robinson. The using of press conference photos became an accepted practice in the trading card industry when a game-action photo could not be secured on time.

But another big change to the hockey card industry was the increased demand for hockey cards in the late 1980s and early 1990s. Two years after Gretzky’s trade to L.A., three more companies got the license to make hockey cards. Hockey card collecting was no longer a two-horse race, with Upper Deck, Score and Pro Set joining Topps and O-Pee-Chee.

Here in the U.S., hockey cards went from being sold only in card shops to being sold everywhere: grocery stores, toy stores, sporting goods stores, comic book stores, gas stations, you name it. This would never had happened if Gretzky was still in Edmonton.

shoes
Be like Mike? Some of us wanted to be like Wayne.

 3. Gretzky’s new endorsement deals raised hockey’s profile in the U.S.
Yes, Wayne Gretzky was endorsing products long before his trade to Los Angeles — including this hilariously-bad 7-Up commercial from Canada — but now he was endorsing products in the U.S., too.

Having a recognizable name and face to promote hockey-related products raised hockey’s profile significantly. Grocery stores carried Upper Deck trading cards, endorsed by Gretzky. Toy stores had the Wayne Gretzky Overtime Hockey table hockey game and the Wayne Gretzky Hockey video game for Nintendo. Shoe stores sold Gretzky-endorsed Ultra Wheels in-line skates and L.A. Gear street hockey shoes.

Street hockey shoes? Tell me about it. Do you think any company would have tried selling street hockey shoes if Gretzky wasn’t with the Kings?

si_cover
Suddenly, Los Angeles noticed that it had a hockey team.

4. Gretzky helped expansion in traditional non-hockey markets
The L.A. Kings — along with the now-defunct Oakland Seals — became NHL teams in 1967 because the television networks wanted the NHL to have a west coast presence. The NHL also did this to thwart their biggest rival at the time, the “old” Western Hockey League. Hockey languished in California in the 1970s and 1980s until Gretzky came along.

Five years later, California had two more teams. Former Kings owner Bruce McNall may have had a lot to do with that. In his book Fun While it Lasted, he discusses pushing for expansion in California so that he’d get a large chunk of the expansion fee money paid by the San Jose Sharks and Anaheim Mighty Ducks, since they were encroaching on the Kings’ TV market.

Face it: no one in Anaheim or San Jose would even be interested in hockey if it wasn’t for Gretzky being on the Kings in the first place. During the 1990s, Gretzky’s presence in the U.S. would help grow the sport in other “non-traditional” markets like Florida and Texas.

hockey_kids
Photo by battlecreekcvb via Flickr / Creative Commons.

5. Gretzky inspired the next generation of American players
More kids wanted to play hockey in the United States after Gretzky was traded to the Kings. The numbered of registered hockey players in California grew from 4,830 players  in 1990-91 (the earliest year that USA Hockey has data for) to 22,305 players in 2010-11 (source). California is the seventh-largest region for hockey players in the United States.

Gretzky’s presense in L.A. was felt throughout the rest of the country, too. According to USA Hockey, the number of registered hockey players in the U.S. grew from 195,125 players in 1990-91 to 421,399 players in 1998-99 — Gretzky’s last year in the NHL. Since then, it has climbed to 510,279 registered players in the U.S.

This has also impacted the number of Americans drafted by NHL teams. From 2000 to 2012, 743 U.S.-born players were drafted by NHL teams. In the 2013 draft, 53 U.S.-born players were drafted, accounting for just over one-fourth of all players picked. How many of these young men were inspired by watching Gretzky play?

***
On August 9, 1988, Canada lost their greatest athlete, but hockey in the United States gained just what it needed to help the sport grow. Twenty five years later, the growth hasn’t stopped.

Review: 2012-13 Rockford IceHogs team set

23_frontThe 2012-13 Rockford IceHogs team set might just be the greatest minor league team set ever made. Consider the cool, retro design that pays homage to old time cards and the plethora of NHL talent included, and you’d be hard pressed to find a more worthwhile team set of minor league players. Continue reading “Review: 2012-13 Rockford IceHogs team set”

2013 Blackhawks Convention day 3 recap

hawks_convention_logoThe third and final day of the 2013 Chicago Blackhawks Convention was only four hours long, starting at 9 a.m. and ending at 1 p.m. However, wristbands for the first group of players would be distributed at 8:30 a.m. There was an outside chance that I could get Bobby Hull’s autograph, as wristband distribution for “The Golden Jet” was at 9:30 a.m. However, fans had already started lining up for Hull — as early as 5 a.m.! Guessing that there were probably more than 315 fans in the line for Hull, I turned my attention elsewhere. Good thing I did, too. Continue reading “2013 Blackhawks Convention day 3 recap”

2013 Blackhawks Convention day 2 recap

hawks_convention_logoSaturday, July 27, 2013
The second day of the Chicago Blackhawks Convention is also the longest, starting at 9 a.m. and going all the way to 7:30 p.m.

One of my “big goals” for this convention was to get as many retired players as possible to sign this book: Continue reading “2013 Blackhawks Convention day 2 recap”

2013 Blackhawks Convention day 1 recap

hawks_convention_logoThis past weekend, I attended the 6th Annual Chicago Blackhawks Convention. The convention is an opportunity for fans to get autographs from the players, attend panel discussions with players and coaches, buy hockey memorabilia, see all the NHL trophies — including the Stanley Cup — and engage in other activities.

Although every year I tell myself that I am going to focus more on attending the panels, I usually spend most of the show getting autographs. And this year, I got autographs from many current and retired players. Continue reading “2013 Blackhawks Convention day 1 recap”

Card of the Week: Kerry Toporowski

1991-92 Ultimate Draft Picks #48 – Kerry Toporowski

1991-92 Ultimate Draft Picks #48 - Kerry ToporowskiWe all love to make fun of crummy hockey cards, from the awful “updated” photos from the 1970s and 1980s, to the cheesy pictures from the 1990s and 2000s. But the worst disservice to both the player and the fans is when the card doesn’t even show what the player looks like.

You may recall the infamous card of goaltender Bryan Pitton in Score’s 2010-11 set, where we see a sweet photograph of the back of his head. Well, this card may be worse. Back in the 1991-92 season, a short-lived card company called Ultimate pulled the same crap. They made a 90-card set of draft picks, but didn’t even bother to show the face of a San Jose Sharks prospect named Kerry Toporowski. In fact, there’s more of his butt on this card than his head!

If you never heard of Toporowski don’t feel bad. Back in 1991, all anyone was talking about was first overall draft pick Eric Lindros. Toporowski was more of a long shot. He was drafted in the 4th round because of his physical style of play. The Sharks soon traded him, along with a second round pick in next year’s draft, to the Chicago Blackhawks for Doug Wilson, who served as the Sharks’ first team captain and all-star representative.

Toporowski never made it to the NHL, and is perhaps best remembered for the ungodly amount of penalty minutes he racked up in junior and minor league hockey. Some of his highlights include:

  • 63 penalty minutes in 3 games for the Spokane Chiefs in the 1991 Memorial Cup Tournament — that’s 21 PIMS per game!
  • 505 penalty minutes in 65 games for the Spokane Chiefs (WHL) in 1990-91.
  • 206 penalty minutes in 18 games with the Indianapolis Ice (IHL) in 1991-92.
  • 413 penalty minutes in 63 games with the Quad City Mallards (ULH) in 2000-01.
  • 52 penalty minutes in 3 games for the Portland Pirates (AHL) in 1997-98.

Seeing as how he was the 67th overall pick, this set would have been no worse if Ultimate excluded Toporowski. Why even bother making a card when the best photo you have is the player falling on top of another player — and it’s from the back?

What’s even more mind boggling is that the photo on the back of the card also shows Toporowski from behind — as if the photographer was afraid he’d break his lens on Kerry’s mug.

1991-92 Ultimate Draft Picks #48 - Kerry Toporowski (back)Yep, the head-to-ass ratio is about the same in this picture too.

And here’s the clincher: the cards from this set are from a photo shoot set-up by the card company. Meaning, Ultimate paid the players to scrimmage so that they could be photographed for the cards. Heck, you even see the goalies’ faces on the backs of their cards, but no one bothered to snap a pick of Toporowski while he was tying his skates?

Over two decades later, and I still find it irksome that a company would try to pass this off as a trading card.

1995-96 Playoff One on One Hockey Challenge prototype cards

modano_protoIn 1995-96, the Playoff Corporation released a 330-card collectible card game (CCG) called One on One Hockey Challenge. The game cards featured the top NHL players at the time, and contained instructions at the top and stats at the bottom that were used for the game. Sometime before the release of the actual game, Playoff released prototype cards that differ from the actual game cards in several interesting ways.  Continue reading “1995-96 Playoff One on One Hockey Challenge prototype cards”

Custom Cards: 1990-91 Pro Set Jaromir Jagr & Martin Brodeur draft pick cards

jagr brodeur
1990-91 Pro Set Hockey Series One consisted of 405 cards. Included were cards of Owen Nolan and Petr Nedved, the first overall and second overall picks in the 1990 NHL Entry Draft. However, Pro Set missed out by NOT including fifth overall pick Jaromir Jagr or 20th pick Martin Brodeur. So I decided to make custom “Draft Picks” cards of these two players.

jagrOther companies, such as Upper Deck and Score, included cards of Jaromir Jagr from draft day. The photo used above is actually taken from Jagr’s Upper Deck rookie card. Pro Set put out a card of Jagr, playing with the Penguins, in Pro Set Series Two later that year.

brodeurMartin Brodeur, on the other hand, never had a Pro Set card. Other than a five game call-up in 1991-92, Brodeur spent 1990 to 1993 either with his junior team or in the minors. For this custom card, I found this photo, which was taken soon after the New Jersey Devils selected Brodeur 20th overall.

Seeing as how utterly comprehensive Pro Set tried to be, I am surprised that they did not issue “draft day” cards of all 21 first round draft picks. That would have made for a nice snapshot of one of the deepest drafts in NHL history.

Question: Looking back 23 years later, who should have been the first overall pick in the 1990 draft: Jaromir Jagr or Martin Brodeur?

Card of the Week: Platinum Pratfall

PC8_blake_fprat·fall  • /ˈpratˌfôl / • Noun

  1. A fall on the buttocks.
  2. A stupid and humiliating action.

This is not a great photo for a hockey card. I mean really — who exactly is flattered by this picture? Defenseman Rob Blake, getting knocked into his own goalie? Or goaltender Kelly Hrudey, about to get his head squished by Blake’s butt? Maybe this photo would make the net-crashing Canuck look cool — if his head was in the frame.

And yet, this is the photo that was used on Rob Blake’s “Sensational Sophomore” insert card in the 1991-92 Pro Set Platinum Hockey set.

Let me rephrase that; a photo of Rob Blake’s ass about to crush Kelly Hrudey’s head was THE photo that Pro Set used for an insert card touting Blake as a “Sensational Sophomore.”

One can only wonder what the REJECTED photographs looked like. The pic might have been better utilized for a goalie mask advertisement: Easton goalie masks – made to withstand being sat on by a 220-pound defenseman.

Blake was a regular in the Kings’ lineup in 1990-91 and 1991-92, so many pictures of him should have been available for Pro Set to choose from that year. Even the picture from the back of the card would have been a better choice for the front, since you can see his face. Oh, and because he doesn’t look like a stooge crushing his own teammate.

Better?
Better?

This was not the first time a defenseman was made to look like a doofus on his own card. Ten years prior, Topps — for some strange reason — used a photo of New York Islanders defenseman  Denis Potvin falling on his own goalie. for his “Super Action” card.

Can you think of any other cards that use a very unflattering picture of a player ON HIS OWN CARD?