Review: Check Out My Cards Purchase

Check Out My Cards logoOn November 23, the online trading card store Check Out My Cards ( had a “Black Friday” sale. For you Canadians, that is what the day after American Thanksgiving is called, since it is the unofficial start of the Christmas shopping season. Retailers would “black out” the schedule for that day–meaning, NO ONE was getting a day off on the day after Thanksgiving; everyone had to show up and work because it would be so busy.

The Black Friday Promotion: Many of the cards on COMC were marked down from their original asking price and shipping was free if you ordered 10 or more cards. Plus, you were given 10 cents store credit for every card you bought. I believe this sale was to help push traffic to beta test their new website, as the old site ( is being phased out for the new one (

A Bit of Background: For those unfamiliar with COMC, their business works a bit differently than other online card sellers like Sportlots or the Beckett Marketplace. Those who wish to sell their trading cards through COMC actually send their cards to COMC, who in turn scans and lists the cards, and then ships them when ordered. This is good for buyers, because you might purchase cards from 20 different sellers, but only pay shipping from the COMC warehouse.

I was going to order from COMC in the past, but until recently their shipping policy was different, charging you an initial fee plus a per-card fee. For example, fellow blogger Shane ordered 169 cards and spent almost $50 to ship an $86 purchase!

So, you can see why I was reluctant to order from COMC. But as I mentioned before, they were offering free shipping on orders placed on Black Friday, negating this extra (and excessive) shipping charge.

Without further ado, here is my review of my COMC purchase.

Website Ease of Use – 5 out of 5: As many of you may know, I am a professional web designer, so I tend to scrutinize sites more than your average card collector. But this is a review of my overall experience of ordering from COMC, and not just their website.

COMC Website
Check Out My Card’s new website.

COMC’s new website was intuitive and easy to use. At the top is a big search box so you can type in what you are looking for; a MUST on any retail website.

Search results show up quickly, and you can easily click on any keywords you initially searched for to see more cards of a given player, set or year. You can also filter for rookie, memorabilia, autographed or serial-numbered cards.

The list view pages–where you see all cards of a player, set or year–are well-designed and offer multiple viewing options to suit your web browsing habits. COMC defaults to a left-to-right gallery view, but you can easily toggle to a top-down list view, a thumbnails-only view and a text-only view.

COMC Website
You can easily sort what order cards are displayed in, and can easily toggle between gallery, list, thumbnail and text-only views.

Pages default to 12 results per page–too low, in my opinion–but you can easily change this to up to 100 items per page. Items can be sorted by price, book value, release year, print run or card number.

Speaking of which, COMC lists the cards in proper numeric order. For example, the Beckett Marketplace will list card 1, then cards 10-19, then cards 100-199, then card 2, then cards 20-29, then cards 200-299, and so forth. This always annoyed me greatly, so I am thankful that COMC orders the cards the way they should be.

2010-11 Artifacts #201 - Cam Fowler
I paid less than half of “book” value for this Cam Fowler redemption rookie card.

Prices – 3 out of 5: Look for any card on COMC, and chances are you will find multiple sellers offering the same card at very different prices. For example, a 1990-91 O-Pee-Chee Premier Jaromir Jagr rookie card–ungraded–ranges from $4.73 to $8.00. Some dealers opted to discount their cards by 20% or more on Black Friday, while others did not.

During the sale, each card’s “book value” was listed alongside its price for each card. I thought this was very helpful in making decisions of what to buy. An “asking price” of $15 for a card “worth” $15 makes me want to look elsewhere first. But if I saw the card had a book value of $15 and an asking price for far less, I did not hesitate. I hope COMC restores this feature.

Common cards were listed “Less Than $1” for their book value. But common cards were COMCs biggest weakness when it came to prices. Cards that should realistically sell for between a nickel and a quarter tended to be priced between 50 to 75 cents. For one card, paying a bit much is no big deal. But if you needed 30 cards to finish off your 1992-93 Upper Deck Hockey set, would you really want to spend $21?

On the other hand, “middle of the road” cards were priced to move. Cards withink the $5 to $20 range were priced competitively, and usually far lower than so-called “book” value. I bought many 2010-11 Artifacts cards, with Beckett values of around $5 for between $1 and $1.50. I also nabbed a Cam Fowler redemption RC (BV of $12) for $5.69 and a Nino Niederreiter redemption RC (BV of $15) for $6.25. Suddenly, overpaying for a few commons did not seem so bad.

Shipping Time – 4 out of 5: I ordered cards on Friday, November 23 and received them on Friday, November 30. I think one week is a fair turnaround time for a card order, especially since mail gets slower around the holidays. There are ways to get your cards faster from COMC, but that depends on your shipping option. Which brings us to our next point…

Shipping Cost – 5 out of 5: Yes, I did get free shipping, but COMC is now charging a flat rate of $3.00 per order, which I think is extremely fair. You can upgrade to “Rapid” shipping for $1.99 more, or Priority Mail for an extra $4.99. There even are faster and more expensive options, too. Orders using basic shipping are packed within a week, while all other shipping options pack and send your order within one business day. Some of these cards I’ve needed for 20 years, so a few extra days won’t affect me.

Packing – 5 out of 5: COMC offers buyers the option to add 20 cents per card to have a card placed in a toploader before shipping. Most of the cards I bought were cheap, so I was not going to pay extra. COMC’s business is selling cards, so of course I’d expect them to be well packed.

But, COMC exceeded my expectations for how my order was packaged. I ordered 58 cards. They came packaged in a 300-count box:

Check Out My Cards mailing box (closed)Inside of that 300-count box was a smaller box that held my cards, along with some Styrofoam packing peanuts and a copy of my order.

Check Out My Cards mailing box (open)Additionally, each card was in a penny sleeve.

Check Out My Cards orderConsidering that this is COMC’s lowest-priced shipping option, I was extremely satisfied. Obviously, I would not expect a larger order (say around 300 cards) to be double-boxed, but putting every card in a penny sleeve by default goes a long way in keeping cards “ding” and edge-wear free during transit.

Overall: Ordering from COMC allowed me to get many cards that I needed from different sellers, but they were all shipped from one location. In the future, this will give me the best of both worlds: a wide variety and inexpensive shipping. COMC is great for mid-to-higher dollar value cards, but not the most cost-efficient way to purchase numerous commons.

Rating 4 out of 5For $3 shipping, I suggest you check out Check Out My Cards and see if they can help you fill a few holes in your set. You can visit their website at


Author: Sal Barry

Sal Barry is the editor and webmaster of Puck Junk. He is a freelance hockey writer, college professor and terrible hockey player. Follow him on Twitter @puckjunk

16 thoughts on “Review: Check Out My Cards Purchase”

    1. Do you guys have “Black Friday,” or do you call it something like “Uncommonly Busy Day of Shopping?” πŸ™‚

  1. Sal,
    I was checking out your site – love it. It is by far the best hockey card site out there. So you’re a hockey junkie, eh? I am curious as to how many sets you have and how you choose which sets to collect – do you have multiple sets going at a time? I am curious as to how you store your cards – with so many you are either very organized or not! You use binders, sleeves, toploaders – just curious? I really love your site – I would love to hear more about your collecting habits, what you have, what you go after and how you go about choosing what sets you collect – any focus?

    Also – how about doing a post showing off your hockey headquarters – I would love to see PuckJunk world headquarters!


    1. LOL, Puck Junk World Headquarters!

      I am going to do a feature about organizing your collection–soon, I promise.

      I collect too many sets at a time. Usually 2-3 current sets, plus any sets from the past 7 years I did not finish, plus any other “project” sets from the 1990s. I have most major sets from 1980 to 1994, but need some of the odder stuff like early OPC sticker sets and regional/oddball and team-issue team sets. I’m all over the map!

  2. I never buy from COMC. I tried to find some cards on that Black Friday sale but I found them all to be too much. I mostly buy base or cheap stuff. However I do use the site a lot, just to see what the cards look like before I buy them on sportlots

  3. You may not have realized it but handling fees are actually worked into the cost of the card on the new web site. On prices are 25 cents lower per card and then a quarter is added to the price when you ship the card out to you. So on the new site they have “$3 shipping” but there is another fee worked into the prices of every card which doesn’t make the overal deal that much better than their previous shipping prices.

    1. Thanks, Matt. . I guess I don’t mind prices being a quarter higher on cards that are in the $5 to $10 range.

  4. COMC has been a GOD-sent for me this year! Running into these fine folks @ the NATIONAL was just what I needed to get back fully into this great Hobby of Sports Card Collecting. Thank You for making it so fun & reasonable again!

  5. great review, but i think somethings were missed that are important when buying form too. like the make an offer feature. alot of sellers, have 1000’s of cards for sell on the site, and reviewing all of them on price changes is difficult, so the make an offer option is a great feature. also alot of the cards that are low cost base that typically sell for a dime or so that can be listed for 75 cents, has a reason behind it too. as a seller i get hit with “storage fees” for cards under 75 cents. so i would suggest that you use the “make an offer’ feature and i would bet most of the sellers would take your 10 cent offer on that 75 cent card. the penny sleve is nice but 99% of the time we sellers send them in protected too, cmoc doesnt add them usually, because they are already in one, all in all a very good review, and as a seller thanks. but i think you should see what selling on this site it like too.


    1. Dave, thank you for giving your perspective on what it is like to sell on COMC. I am aware of the storage fees, as I did look into their selling policies. I was also aware of the “Make an Offer” option, but that only works when you have store credit, which I did not have at the time. I guess I wanted to place an order all at once on Friday, which is why I did not try the “Offer” feature.

      1. thats true you do have to have “credit” but if you know your already going to buy then it can be prudent to add credit and save even more moohhhhla lol. and again thanks for the review.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *