Card of the Week: Steve Swap

1983-84 O-Pee-Chee #105: Steve Larmer & #106: Steve Ludzik Error Cards

Steve Larmer Rookie Card (photo actually Steve Ludzik)Everyone makes mistakes, but for some reason trading card companies seem to make them in droves. Who can keep track of all those names and numbers, teams, logos and statistics? Back in 1983, O-Pee-Chee made what I still consider two of the most annoying error cards ever.

Chicago Blackhawks winger Steve Larmer scored 43 goals and 47 assists in the 1982-83 campaign and was awarded the Calder Memorial Trophy as the NHL’s rookie of the year. The same season, fellow Blackhawks’ player Steve Ludzik skated in 66 games, scoring six goals and 19 assists. Both players earned rookie cards in the 1983-84 O-Pee-Chee hockey set, but with one glaring mistake – their photos were swapped, as Larmer’s card (#105) shows Ludzik, while Ludzik’s card (#106) pictures Larmer.

Steve Ludzik Rookie Card (photo actually Steve Larmer)Steve Larmer Rookie Card (photo actually Steve Ludzik)Will the real Steve Larmer rookie card please stand up?

Normally, one can see how easy of a mistake this was to make. Both guys were named Steve, had two-syllable surnames beginning with L and played for the Chicago Blackhawks. Larmer wore jersey number 28, while Ludzik wore 29. Even their career paths mimicked each other – both were born in Ontario, drafted in 1980, played three years of junior hockey for the Niagara Falls Flyers (1978-81), and spent the 1981-82 season in the minors with the AHL’s New Brunswick Hawks. Additionally, both Steves were left-handed shots and roughly the same age, height and weight.

Steve LarmerSteve Ludzik Rookie Card (back)So, if O-Pee-Chee had misspelled a name, gotten the stats wrong, or something to that extent, we’d all understand. Likewise, mistaking Bob Kelly for J. Bob Kelly or Duane Sutter for Darryl Sutter would almost be excusable. But screwing up the card of the NHL rookie of the year is ridiculous and lazy on the card maker’s part – especially when the same dude also appears in the same set on a trophy winner card. Fortunately, they got that photo right.

Steve Larmer / Calder Trophy WinnerLarmer had an admirable career, scoring 1012 points (441 goals and 771 assists) in 1006 games – averaging just over a point-per-game in his 13-years in the NHL. He is also third all-time in the NHL for consecutive games played with 884 straight contests, never missing one from 1982 to 1993. Only Doug Jarvis (964) and Gary Unger (916) had longer “iron man” streaks. Larmer appeared in two All-Star Games, and helped the New York Rangers win the Stanley Cup in 1994.

Conversely, Ludzik played six seasons in the NHL, and then petered out in the minors. He did find success behind the bench, coaching for ten seasons, including a two-year stint as head coach of the Tampa Bay Lightning (1999-01)

This photographic gaffe devalues Larmer’s card while at the same time rescues Ludzik’s RC from languishing in the commons bin. Today, Larmer’s rookie card is valued around $8, and would probably be worth more if it actually pictured him. Ludzik’s card – which should be worth no more than the stick of gum that it came with – sells for roughly $2. Many times, you’ll find both sold as a pair, since it really does not make sense to own one without the other.

Love hockey? Join the Puck Junk Facebook Group, subscribe to Puck Junk on Apple Podcasts and  YouTube, and support this site at the Puck Junk Online Shop

Follow Sal Barry on Twitter @PuckJunk


Author: Sal Barry

Sal Barry is the editor and webmaster of Puck Junk. He is a freelance hockey writer, college professor and terrible hockey player. Follow him on Twitter @puckjunk

6 thoughts on “Card of the Week: Steve Swap”

  1. Hi,
    Before just recently I retylired from owning a hobby shop in Santa Fe,NM and a whole box of err & UERs from all sports and I must admit that thought that one day I’d retire on them,lol.Anyway long story short.To me the Topps & O Pee Chee blunders and airbrushed hockey cards was the reason I collected them to today.They’re just to funny to look at especially the 80s with all the defunct teams finding new home.Colorado becoming New Jersey, Atlanta becoming Calgary just to name a couple.I still collect errors of all kinds to add to my PC in hope of one day of making a gallery of them on the internet for others to enjoy.Thank you @puckjunk for providing the ones you’ve shown so far and if you need anymore,lmk how I can mail you some and I will gladly send you pics and the screwups behind them.
    Thank you

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *